October 2026

The real disadvantages of annuities

We connect retirees with an advisor, and we still think the honest version of this article is worth writing. Here is where annuities actually fall short.

A retiree at a living room table reviewing a document with a calm, contemplative expression

We built this site to connect North Texas retirees with a licensed advisor, and we still think it is worth writing the honest version of this article instead of the version that only lists upsides. Annuities solve real problems for some people and are a poor fit for others. Here is where they genuinely fall short.

Your money is tied up for a stretch of years

Most fixed and fixed indexed annuities carry a surrender period, often somewhere in the 5 to 10 year range, during which pulling out more than the free withdrawal amount triggers a charge. If there is a real chance you will need a large sum of that money back within a few years, for a medical event, a move, or anything else, an annuity is the wrong place to put it. We go into the specifics in our surrender charge breakdown.

Fixed-rate products can lose ground to inflation

A multi-year guaranteed annuity locks in a rate for a set term. If that rate is lower than inflation over the same period, the real, inflation-adjusted value of your money quietly shrinks even though the account statement shows growth every year. This is not unique to annuities, a savings account or a CD has the same exposure, but it is a real tradeoff for the certainty an MYGA offers.

Fees and commissions are built into the product

Annuities are not free to administer, and the advisor who sells one is typically compensated by the insurance company, not by a separate fee you pay directly. That is not inherently dishonest, but it means the product's structure and the advisor's incentive are worth understanding together, not separately. A fixed indexed annuity with a lifetime income rider often carries an ongoing rider fee on top of the base contract, which reduces the account value over time in exchange for the guarantee.

They are genuinely complicated contracts

Participation rates, cap rates, spread fees, rider costs, and surrender schedules are all real terms that materially change what a contract actually pays out, and two annuities that look similar on a one-page summary can perform very differently once you read the full contract. Complexity is not automatically bad, but it does mean you should not buy one from a summary alone.

They are not a replacement for every other financial tool

An annuity is one piece of a retirement income plan, not the whole plan. Someone with a large, diversified portfolio and no immediate need for guaranteed income may not need one at all. Someone with most of their savings already committed to illiquid real estate may be a poor candidate for a product that adds another layer of illiquidity.

When an annuity still makes sense anyway

None of this means annuities are bad products. It means they are specific tools for specific problems, mainly protecting a portion of savings from market risk or converting savings into guaranteed income you cannot outlive. If that specific problem matches your situation, the tradeoffs above are usually worth it. If it does not, they are not.

Annuities are long-term insurance contracts issued and guaranteed by the issuing insurance company, not by RetireNorthTexas, and are not FDIC insured, not bank deposits, and not insured by any federal government agency. Guarantees are backed by the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the issuing insurer. Surrender charges, withdrawal limits and other restrictions may apply. This site provides general information only and is not personalized financial, investment, tax or legal advice. Talk to a licensed advisor about your specific situation before making any decision.

Call Now Get Started